So, Ellen's the new American Idol judge

new

« Prev
1
Next »

Jughead
Moderator

Posts: 1,891

So, Ellen's the new American Idol judge Sept 13, 2009 12:13:54 GMT -5

Quote

Post by Jughead on Sept 13, 2009 12:13:54 GMT -5

Old news, I know...

So, what do you all think about this news?

I think we all agree that Paula Abdul leaving was inevitable. But, how do you all feel about Ellen DeGeneres taking over her spot?

I know some have criticized the choice, mainly citing the fact that she has no musical background. I think it's brilliant myself. She gives the perspective of judging from the fan's point of view. She's now taken on the "nice" judge chair. And, I think it could be hilarious to see her and Simon banter with each other.

I don't know if ANYONE here watches American Idol (I'm thinking not too many of you do). But, what's your take?

Last Edit: Sept 13, 2009 12:14:29 GMT -5 by Jughead

"Every heartbeat babe, is a soundtrack to your life..."

- Kylie Minogue, "Sweet Music" (2003)

Dawn
Administrator

AKA MusicGal

"I know there's an answer..."

Posts: 11,168

So, Ellen's the new American Idol judge Sept 15, 2009 18:07:00 GMT -5

Quote

Post by Dawn on Sept 15, 2009 18:07:00 GMT -5

I watched AI pretty regularly during seasons 2 through 7, but only sporadically last year.

I don't think Ellen is a bad choice. As you said, she brings more a fan's perspective to the table, and that might make for some interesting dynamics. The show definitely needs a breath of fresh air.

The main problem with AI, I think, isn't with Paula Abdul or Ellen, but the fact that it's starting to show its age. A lot of the freshness has worn off, and even with different contestants each year, it's starting to feel a bit same-y. Randy's "Yo dawg, check it out" and "that was kinda pitchy, dude" banter has gotten old, and even Simon seems to be uninterested at times.